Two-Unit Historic Property Case Study

339 S Orange St, Orange
Sold for $1.3M With the ADU Tenant in Place

Old Towne Orange Historic District Craftsman + ADU · Orange, CA 92866

$1,400,000 Original List Price July 2024
$1,300,000 Final Closed Price Tenant in Place
70 Days On Market (MLS) Jul–Oct 2024
2 Units Home + ADU on One Lot 2,017 SF Total

Sold October 16, 2024. The property listed at $1,400,000 on July 4 and was reduced twice before going pending; the full price history is in the transaction timeline below. This result is one example from our complete Orange County seller’s playbook. To see how location changes pricing and timelines, read North vs. South Orange County home selling.

Front exterior of 339 S Orange St, a 1913 Craftsman home in the Old Towne Orange Historic District
Old Towne Orange Historic Craftsman + ADU · 4 Bed / 3 Bath · 2,017 SF Total
The Challenge & The Friction

A Two-Unit Historic Property With Several Layers

The owner of 339 S Orange St had held the Old Towne Orange property since 1987, about 37 years, and had been renting both the main house and the ADU above the detached garage. Ready to simplify his responsibilities, travel more and eventually relocate out of state to be closer to family, he saw the sale as an important step in that transition.

After 37 years there was a strong emotional attachment, and as a previously licensed real estate agent he also had his own opinions about pricing and preparation. He initially wanted to start at a higher price than we recommended and preferred to make only limited improvements before going to market. Rather than push him into renovations or decisions he wasn’t comfortable making, we worked within his parameters and used actual buyer activity and market feedback to guide the process.

The property also needed careful positioning. It had desirable historic character and income potential, but portions of the home were dated and some earlier updates didn’t complement its original architecture. And the seller had recently renewed the lease with the ADU tenant: several interested buyers wanted the property delivered vacant, but he wasn’t willing to displace a tenant with a newly renewed lease.

Listing Audit Summary

Property Record
Seller’s Preference
Limited Improvements; Higher Starting Price
Property Condition
Dated Areas; Earlier Updates Not Period-Matched
Buyer-Concern Feature
ADU Tenant With a Newly Renewed Lease
Launch List Strategy
$1,400,000 (Reduced Twice Before Closing)
1Vision Executed Sale
$1,300,000 Tenant in Place
No major renovation required of the seller
Location & Configuration

Marketing Potential, Not a Finished Product

Instead of presenting the property as fully updated, we marketed what is hard to replicate: its Old Towne Orange location, historic character, two-unit configuration and the flexibility created by the ADU.

Historic Character Living and dining rooms with original wood wainscoting, columns and hardwood floors at 339 S Orange St, Orange

Original Woodwork & Craftsman Details

Built in 1913 in the Old Towne Orange Historic District, a few blocks from Chapman University and the Orange Circle per the listing description. Original details like wainscoting, columns and built-ins gave a future owner something to restore and build on.

Income Flexibility Detached garage with the ADU above it and a private entrance stair at 339 S Orange St, Orange

ADU Above the Detached Garage

The listing described a roughly 583-square-foot second unit with its own address, separately metered utilities and a private entrance, suited to rental income or extended family. The existing tenant was positioned as part of that income opportunity.

Diego Magdaleno, REALTOR in Orange County - 1Vision Real Estate
Diego Magdaleno · Lead Strategist
Strategic Thesis

Respecting What the Seller Is Comfortable Doing

Not every successful sale is about creating a bidding war or selling in a matter of days. Sometimes the strategy is balancing the seller’s financial goals with the realities of the property and, especially for a longtime senior owner, respecting what he is actually comfortable doing.

"We focused on finding a buyer whose plans aligned with the property as it actually existed, rather than asking the seller to make changes he wasn’t comfortable making."

We kept marketing through a challenging interest-rate environment, listened closely to buyer feedback, and let real market activity guide our pricing and preparation decisions.

Operational Playbook

The Three-Pillar Framework

How we sold a historic two-unit property as it was, with the ADU tenant in place, and closed at $1,300,000 without major renovations.

01 Positioning

Market the Potential

Instead of presenting the property as fully updated, we marketed its potential: a future owner could restore more of the home’s original character while benefiting from a second dwelling that could provide rental income and help offset the cost of ownership.

02 Tenant Strategy

Tenant as Income

The existing ADU tenant was positioned as part of the income opportunity rather than simply an obstacle to the sale. The seller wasn’t willing to displace a tenant with a newly renewed lease, so we looked for a buyer who would take the property with the tenancy in place.

03 Market Response

Listening to Buyers

Per the MLS record, the property listed July 4, 2024 at $1,400,000, was reduced to $1,349,000 on August 9 and to $1,300,000 on September 10, went pending September 13, and closed October 16 at $1,300,000. We kept marketing through higher interest rates and listened closely to buyer feedback.

Measurable Impact

The Final Outcome

$1.3M Final Closed Price
70 Days On Market (MLS)
2 Units Home + ADU, Tenant in Place

"The lesson from this sale: respect what a longtime owner is comfortable doing, then find the buyer whose plans fit the property as it actually is."

— Diego Magdaleno · REALTOR® | CA DRE# 01952035 · 1Vision Real Estate

Public Listing Record

The Transaction Timeline

Milestone Date / Figure What It Establishes
Seller’s ownership Since 1987 (team-reported) About 37 years of ownership
ADU lease renewed Before listing (team-reported) Existing tenancy a buyer would take on
Listing launch July 4, 2024 · $1,400,000 Initial asking price (CRMLS)
First price change August 9, 2024 · $1,349,000 First reduction (about 3.6%)
Second price change September 10, 2024 · $1,300,000 Second reduction (about 3.6%)
Pending status September 13, 2024 Pending three days after the second reduction
Closed sale October 16, 2024 · $1,300,000 Final transaction price

Price analysis: The sale closed at $1,300,000, $100,000 (about 7.1%) below the $1,400,000 initial asking price and equal to the final asking price. The figure is not a measure of net proceeds; repair, carrying and closing costs are not documented here.

Source: Homes.com property history for 339 S Orange St (CRMLS data, MLS# PW24130105). The seller’s ownership history, preferences, ADU lease and buyer feedback are described in the team’s account.

What Longtime Owners Can Learn

Selling a longtime property doesn’t have to mean a full renovation. If an owner isn’t comfortable with major work, ask which buyers are best matched to the property as it is, how an existing tenancy affects value, and what market feedback says about price.

If tenants are in place, review the lease terms and notice requirements before listing, and ask a real estate attorney how a buyer assuming the tenancy affects timing and financing. This Orange transaction is an as-is, tenant-in-place sale example; results vary by property and market.

Strategic Advisory

Unlock Your Property's True Leverage

Own a longtime rental, a two-unit property, or a home with a tenant in place? Let’s build a plan that works with how you want to sell, including what you’re comfortable updating and how an existing tenancy fits.

As-Is Strategy Review
Tenant-in-Place Planning
Zero Obligation
Schedule 30-Min Strategy Call
Direct 1-on-1 with Diego Magdaleno • Instant Calendar Confirmation
Planning an OC Sale? Speak Directly with Diego
Call (714) 681-1222